≡ Top 10 Most Outrageous (And Problematic) “America’s Next Top Model” Moments 》 Her Beauty

Top 10 Most Outrageous (And Problematic) “America’s Next Top Model” Moments

In the early and mid-2000s, “America’s Next Top Model” had us in a chokehold. While the show is a nostalgic TV staple for many viewers, a recently released docu-series on Netflix showed the brutal behind-the-scenes and harsh reality of what it was really like for aspiring models. The show inspired us to look back at some of the craziest (and most problematic) moments that kept us hooked for so many seasons.

“I was rooting for you, we were all rooting for you!”

We all remember Tiffany Richardson from Cycle 4 due to Tyra’s epic crashout, forever cemented in pop culture history. With a full monologue where Tyra humiliated poor Tiffany on stage, saying her own mother would yell at her like this out of love. This piece of bullying-filled footage did not age well.

The pendulum runway

Honestly, who came up with the challenges for this show? In a challenge where giant swinging pendulums adorned the runway, model Alexandra from Cycle 15was prompty pushed off the runway by one of the pendulums, falling flat on her rear end.

That time models were asked to portray other races and ethnicities

This was diabolical and completely racist. Models on ANTM were forced to portray races and ethnicities other than their own not once, but twice. First in Cycle 4 for  “Got Milk?” ad campaign (blackface and racial stereotyping ensued), and then Cycle 13, with a race-swapping challenge using makeup.

Keenyah was sexually harassed and criticized for her weight

In Cycle 4, model Keenyah Hill was put through the ringer. In one episode, she was harassed and felt uncomfortable around a male model touching and breathing on her. At judging, Bank told her to use her “feminine wiles” to shut down harassment.  Then, she was fat-shamed and given “Gluttony” in a Seven Deadly Sins challenge. In an animal challenge, she was given an elephant.

Judges made one contestant close the gap in her teeth but widened the gap in another model’s teeth

The makeover episode is iconic in every ANTM episode, and in Cycle 6, model Dani Evans was sent to a dentist to have her teeth closed. She didn’t go through with it, but Tyra called her out for not having a “marketable” smile. Even so, she won the season. Then in Cycle 15, Banks had a model’s gap widened, furthering the controversy.

A model was told to kiss a male model who made racist comments towards her

In Cycle 7, Episode 9, “The Girl Who Breaks Down,” model Jaeda Young opened up to Tyra about a racist comment made by a male model who she was meant to kiss while filming her CoverGirl commercial. The model said he didn’t like Black girls, and she felt uncomfortable kissing him. She was later called out by Tyra and the other judges for not handling the situation well and was eliminated.

Winnie Harlow was called a “panda”

Today, you might know Winnie Harlow as a top model, but she rose to fame on Cycle 21 of ANTM, where she competed under her birth name, Chantelle. She has a skin condition called vitiligo that causes depigmentation, and in Episode 13, photo consultant Yu Tsai said she looked like a panda and a cow because of the condition.

Contestants were regularly placed in triggering, dangerous photoshoots

It seemed as though producers would plan the photoshoot to get a reaction out of the models – one model was forced to pose in cold water until she convulsed and got hypothermia. Another was made to pose in a grave just hours after one of her childhood best friends died in a car accident. Then there was the time models were forced to pose with furry tarantulas on their faces in Cycle 3.

Joanie brutally had four teeth removed and has bite issues to this day

Joanie from Cycle 6 was made to have teeth removed in a completely unethical and dangerous add-on to her makeover. Her perfectly healthy teeth were extracted by a dentist who messed up the work so badly that the pain lasted long after the procedure, leading to years of agonizing mouth pain.

Shandy was sexually assaulted on camera, and producers turned it into “cheating drama”

Shandy Sullivan from Cycle 2 had her horrifying story told in the Netflix docu-series. Her long-term boyfriend encouraged her to go on the show, and during the models’ trip to Milan, she was blackout drunk and sexually assaulted by a male model in a hot tub. No one intervened, and the show then created a cheating narrative, filming a call to her boyfriend, as well as her asking the man who assaulted her if he used protection.